The Problem with Breastfeeding Advice

Breast milk – it’s nature’s brain food and the best start to life you can give to your baby.  If you want to raise a smart kid, then breastfeeding is one of the things you can do to give your child a headstart.  So why aren’t more mothers offering it to their babies?  Whenever the topic comes up for discussion, I often hear other mothers telling me how they really wanted to breastfeed their babies but they didn’t have enough milk.

Although there are medical cases where mothers really do not have enough milk, it is a rare occurrence.  If the problem of not having enough breast milk to meet a baby’s needs is such a common problem, what did mothers in the past feed their babies back in the days before formula became an option?  I believe that the reason why so many women have trouble breastfeeding is because of lack of appropriate information.

There is information everywhere.  Just google “breastfeeding” and you will find millions of links to information about it.  The question is, how reliable is that information?

I read a lot about breastfeeding while I was pregnant with Gavin.  I thought I knew everything there was to know.  But when Gavin was born, I found myself stumbling.  My nipples were sore, I couldn’t get him to latch on properly, I didn’t have any milk, etc.  It was so bad at times that I wanted to cry.

We know breastfeeding is a good thing to do.  The problem is that most of us don’t know how to breastfeed a baby.  No amount of reading can prepare you for that – especially when the information is not particularly reliable.  Tumbling Boobs and PhD in Parenting highlight some of the reasons why this information is unreliable – it’s because it comes from infant formula companies.

Tumbling Boobs puts it very well: “The absurdity of a formula company creating a breastfeeding advice line is in the same league as a bacon company sponsoring a kosher food festival.”

PhD in Parenting asks: “If you wanted to eat a healthy lunch, but had a craving to scarf down two Mars bars instead, would you call the Mars company for advice on how to curb your cravings? If you were trying to get in shape and exercise, but didn’t feel like going for your morning run, would you call your couch potato friend who always tries to convince you to skip your workouts and join her on the couch? If you were struggling to remain faithful to your spouse, would you call the hot guy who is always flirting with you at work for advice? If you were struggling with breastfeeding, but really wanted to continue, would you call an infant formula manufacturer for advice?”

Unfortunately, the formula companies are often the ones aggressively pushing information.  If they aren’t pushing the information, they are sponsoring it, for example, WebMD’s guide to breastfeeding is sponsored by Gerber.

While some information presented is useful, others can be misleading and completely unhelpful. For example, one thing I read about breastfeeding before I had Gavin was that you should breastfeed for 10-20 minutes on each side, every two to four hours.  When I tried that, the nurses were constantly sending him back to me because he was still hungry.  Even after Gavin, I still assumed that information was correct.  I thought it didn’t work for me because Gavin was a big baby (4kgs at birth) with a larger stomach, therefore, needing more time on the breast to fulfill his feeding needs.

When I had Gareth, I didn’t make the same mistake.  I just let him suckle until I was sure he was really done.  On one occasion, he was on the breast for two hours straight.  After that, he went back to the nursery to sleep under the UV lights (for jaundice) and didn’t come back to me until six hours later!  Then again, Gareth was even bigger than Gavin – 4.5kgs at birth.

It wasn’t until I read the comments from other mothers on KellyMom’s Facebook page that I realised it was the information that was flawed rather than my babies being “the exceptions to the rule”.  If you need information about breastfeeding, make sure you get it from reliable websites, like KellyMom.  If you’re going to take advice about breastfeeding from someone, make sure she’s a mother who has successfully breastfed her child(ren) before, otherwise, it’s just hearsay.


 Powered by Max Banner Ads 

How Many Colours in a Rainbow?

I have a gripe about some of the educational materials that children are exposed to.  It relates to the colours of the rainbow.  Every adult knows that rainbows have seven colours.  Well, okay, since we’re being pedantic, rainbows are basically the splitting of visible light into a spectrum of colours of which seven are most prominently visible – red, orange, yellow, green, blue, indigo and violet.

Yet, when you watch many of the childrens’ programs around, they teach children that there are only six colours of the rainbow – red, orange, yellow, green, blue and purple.  Indigo and violet have been lumped together under purple.

I don’t understand what the purpose of this “simplification” is for.  What’s the matter?  You think a child who has learned how to walk, talk and develop a basic understanding of the world around them in as little as two to three years cannot learn the names of an additional two colours?

Considering the magnitude of information that a child absorbs in the early years of growing up, I think it is sheer arrogance for adults to think that a child cannot absorb the knowledge of another two colours into their already vast database of information about the world.

1198530_somwhere_over_the_rainbow___


 Powered by Max Banner Ads 

 Powered by Max Banner Ads 

Skeptical Parent Crossing 5 is Up!

I’ve always felt that parenting is a subject that needs to be taken more seriously.  I’ve been told before that parenting should be about following our “instincts” and while that is generally good advice, sometimes instincts alone aren’t enough.  After all, what are instincts but the extrapolation of our own experiences?

If you happened to be from the era of nuclear families, then you would know even less about parenting from first hand experience.  For some, the first time they come in close contact with a baby is when they have their own.  For instance, I am the younger child within a family of two children.  While my baby isn’t the first one I have been in close contact with, I still felt poorly educated to deal with raising a child.

There comes a time, therefore, when we need to do some background research for the benefit of ourselves and our children; when we need to question the well-meaning advices from friends and family.  Only by looking at the options and the evidence supporting it can we make educated choices as opposed to falling back to that age-old belief of “well, that’s how I was raised and I turned out okay”.

In this day and age where information is in abundance, we can no longer claim the ignorance of our parents’ generation that we did “not know any better”.  With information abound, it is not only important that we seek expert advice, but that we critically question and examine the advice we are being given (remember that the experts of our parents’ generation promoted formula milk over breast milk).

This is the ultimate goal of Skeptical Parenting Crossing – that we not only seek to learn more about parenting but that we question what we are being told to determine its validity.

The 5th Edition of Skeptical Parent Crossing is up!  Go check it out!


 Powered by Max Banner Ads 

 Powered by Max Banner Ads