Early Childhood Education – Formal Classes or Home School?

During my accidental visit to Steps Ahead Learners, I signed Gavin up for a trial cooking class which was supposed to take place on Friday.  Although I had tried taking Gavin to a few mother and toddler music and gym classes last year when he was about 19-20 months old, I finally gave up when it seemed clear that Gavin was NOT enjoying class and would rather be anywhere but in the room.

You are welcome to read about our experiences:

After that, I quit the classes.

Since Gavin is now two, I thought perhaps it was time to try again.  Actually, I wasn’t really planning to try again until he turned three, but when I heard they offered cooking classes at Steps Ahead Learners, I was encouraged to try again because Gavin loves cooking.  Okay, let me rephrase that – ever since he was little, he has had this magnetic fascination for the kitchen and the things that happened inside it.  He loved to watch my MIL cook, he loved to play with cooking sets (his god sisters) and he thoroughly enjoyed himself when we gave him the wok, the frying spatula and a few “ingredients” for his secret recipe.

resized_2008_01080007

When my SIL, the chef, returned for a holiday, Gavin would often be her “little helper” in the kitchen (although I’m not exactly sure whether he helped much or if he created more work).  When he hears the sound of the mixer, he would come running into the kitchen and demand to be picked up so he can take a look at what was happening inside.

Naturally when I heard cooking class, I felt a ray of hope that we could possibly have found a class that he might be keen to try after all…

So on Friday, when Gavin woke up, I asked him, “Would you like to go to cooking class?”

I was delighted when he nodded eagerly and was keen to get going.  We had breakfast, hopped into the car and found a lovely parking spot right next to the complex entrance.  All was great until we walked up to the door of Steps Ahead Learners.  Gavin saw where we were going and he no longer wanted to attend cooking class.  He was mildly protesting but not howling and screaming like he was during our previous experiences so I thought we could at least peek into the class to see what was going on.

We got inside, took off our shoes and one of the teachers approached us.  I told her we were attending the cooking class and she looked confused.  Apparently there are no cooking classes on Friday.  Cooking classes are only on Wednesdays.  She also told me that class starts at 9:30am.

Now it was my turn to be confused.  When I booked Gavin’s trial class last week, Vicky, the vice principal, told me we could come in on Friday at any time before 11am.  I had specifically told her I was only interested in the cooking class and nothing else and even mentioned my experiences taking Gavin to class on previous occasions.

Anyway, the teacher then told me I might as well come back next Wednesday for the trial cooking class.  Given Gavin’s negative response and the school’s rather disorganised manner handling our trial class, I decided that perhaps we won’t be coming back.  I wasn’t too happy to have dragged Gavin to a shopping complex that was undergoing major renovations (it was very dusty and noisy) for a trial class that didn’t happen.

In the end, I took Gavin shopping and bought him some art supplies for our own private art class – more about that in another post (Homeschooling a toddler – art class).  Gavin obviously hasn’t warmed up to the idea of going to class (even with Mummy present), but then, he’s only two so I’m not sweating it.  I’ve decided we can wait another year or two before we try again.

The whole purpose of these classes is for him to interact with other children.  Since he doesn’t want to go, I figure that if I force him, he’ll just sit in a corner and not participate.  Additionally, I would be creating a very negative experience of school.  I know that he isn’t anti-social because he gets along with his two godsisters like a house on fire.  Although he’s fairly aloof around other children (and even adults) on the first meeting, I’ve noticed that after a few play dates, he warms up pretty well.  Recently, I took him to the jungle gym to play with K, the daughter of one of my friends.  By the second play date, he was calling after her to follow him and would actively seek her out.

As for the things he can learn at these classes…  Well, I’ve attended a few classes with him and I don’t really see any activities that I can’t replicate at home.  Besides, he seems to be progressing just fine without formal classes.  One mother recently commented that he was speaking a lot for a two year old.  Another mother thought he was three years old based on his language skills.  Since I don’t know either of them personally, I’m taking it for granted that they weren’t just being polite.

So I guess I’m just going to home school him until he’s old enough to attend kindergarten.  We had our first “class” on Friday and I thought it went marvelously.  Well, there were a few minor glitches, but more about that in the next post…

About the author

Shen-Li Shen-Li is a stay-home mum to two boys who have been the inspiration for her interest in early childhood development and early child education. She searches for the balance in child development methods and the educational philosophies that will enable the nurture of happy, confident and successful children. She shares her views and findings at Figur8.


 Powered by Max Banner Ads 

Comments

  1. It’s interesting how kids have their own little personalities from early on, such as being more reserved around people they don’t know.

    That’s awesome that you can be home with him. I was slow to warm up to people when I was very small. I think I would have hated if I necessity required that I be thrust into situations for which I wasn’t ready or comfortable.

  2. Yes, at times like these I’m really glad I don’t have to work so I don’t have to traumatise my son by forcing him into situations he isn’t comfortable out of necessity.

  3. Hi, I happen to hit your blog when trying to find out more about home schooling since I plan to home school my baby. Do you mind if I ask you what method of home school you use? Thanks in advance.

  4. Hi Evelyn. I’m afraid I didn’t really follow any specific method of home schooling. I did read about the Montessori program and got the gist of the program. I even tried adapting our room a little to follow the descriptions in the book I read, but I didn’t do much more than that.

    Most activities we ended up doing were all geared towards fun, educational activities, such as going to the science museum, visiting the dinosaur exhibits, looking at musical instruments in a music shop, etc. It was more to offer exposure and possibly ignite some curiosity in my son. We stay with what he finds interesting and move off if he isn’t.

    I know this is not exactly a specific method but it worked for us.

    I also tried few other things like flash cards, trying to teach him to read, etc. There is an abundance of information on this. I wrote about what I found out on baby education – the posts are listed under “education” on my articles page. Feel free to check them out or ask me anything further.

  5. Yeah, read it already. That’s what intrigue me. Wow.. that’s wonderful. That’s what I imagine of educating my baby. Of course there’s a lot to ask. Like, how about the school’s certification? Those legal things if Gavin is going to go to school one day. You stayed in Singapore, am I correct? Sorry to ask those things since the actual thing I could find is only on blogs.

  6. Actually, I’m in Malaysia. As far as I’ve heard (although I have no authority on this source), I don’t think it is legal to homeschool a child completely. I was referring to homeschooling during the early years – before kindergarten and primary.

    I have heard through a friend about a mother who homeschooled her daughters here. There is apparently a way around the legal aspects of it but it requires the child to actually be enrolled in a proper school. There is no certification as far as I know.

    A friend of mine knows the mother personally and she was very impressed by how intelligent and capable the girls were. These girls never formally went to school though – completely homeschooled. They are now fully grown up.

    I’ve been meaning to talk to my friend about how it was done. I’ll let you know when I find out more.

  7. I’m Indonesian. Here, we can’t do it completely as well. There’s a kind of group meeting to attend several times a week. And so, we still have to enroll on a certain method then. It’s not fully up to us to teach our kids.

    Some parents I knew who choose the total home schooling, they use a certain method from US, have the books send here and once in a while go there to get some certification.

    I really appreciate for the insights and also for the updates, of course I’ll wait. Just let me know.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] yet another disastrous attempt to start Gavin on formal classes, I finally decided I’m not going to bother trying to take him to those toddler classes any [...]

  2. [...] our disappointing experience with Steps Ahead Learners, I decided to create my own curriculum for Gavin and came up with the following [...]

  3. [...] we never got around to attending that trial cooking class at Steps Ahead Learners, I decided to run my own “cooking class” at home.  Admitedly, [...]

  4. [...] regular updates on what’s new at Babylicious. Thanks for visiting!Since I started down the road of homeschooling Gavin, I’ve been hearing about a lot of early childhood educational programs that have left my head [...]

Speak Your Mind

*